Business Food & Drink

She Started Making Ice Pops Because Her Kids Were Picky Eaters. Inside PopCentric, North Haven’s Popsicle Shop on State Street

Victoria DeCristofaro started PopCentric in 2015 to sneak fruit past her picky kids. Today her State Street shop makes all-natural pops, from Strawberry Lemon to Coconut Avocado, and sends a pop truck all over Connecticut. Here’s what to order.

Four PopCentric ice pops, Fruit Salad, Pineapple Orange Banana, Strawberry Lemon and Lychee Lime, laid out in their wrappers in front of their flavor cards

Victoria DeCristofaro never planned to own a popsicle shop. She had picky boys at home, a long career at a New Haven-area restaurant and a frustration with the freezer aisle, where the ice pops were full of artificial colors and refined sugar. So in 2015 she started making her own. Eleven years later, PopCentric Gourmet Ice Pops is still hand-pouring them at 55 State St. in North Haven.

The little shop has a 4.9-star rating on Google, and customers keep using the same word for it. “What a gem to have in North Haven,” Anna wrote in a recent Google review. “Simple ingredients. No junk! Popsicles are delicious and big!”

The PopCentric Gourmet Ice Pops shop at 55 State St. in North Haven, with pop-shaped decals and “All natural real fruit, hand crafted, gourmet” painted on the windows

A mom, a restaurant kitchen and a parking lot

“I had picky kids that wouldn’t eat anything,” Victoria told WFSB in 2022. “I really thought my kids would just follow suit and they did not, and they were very resistant and so I would try to make it at home and try to sneak stuff into things, and that was kind of the idea at the beginning.”

She came up with the idea while working at a restaurant and tried the first batches on friends and family. The owner of Tre Scalini, the restaurant where she had worked for 25 years, let her use its kitchen, and she sold at farmers’ markets. Between markets, she told the Daily Nutmeg, “I was basically meeting moms in parking lots on the corner because I didn’t have an actual location that they could go to.”

After that first summer, she fixed up the State Street storefront, and PopCentric has been there ever since. Some of the original sneak-the-vegetables flavors stayed on the menu for years, like Mango Carrot Orange and Strawberry Beet. But customers kept asking for Cookies and Cream and Nutella, so she started making pops “for everyone.”

Two PopCentric ice pops, one pink and one pale green, held up in front of a hand-painted “Squeeze the Day” chalkboard sign

Today PopCentric calls itself “a Connecticut-born obsession with real fruit” and “the architecture of the perfect freeze.” Every pop is still made in small batches in Connecticut, with local herbs and seasonal fruit. The shop is proudly mom-owned. Its website even warns that school closings, sick days or bad weather can change the hours.

Sponsored Partner

The North Haven Courier may be paid a small commission on partner offers at no cost to you.

What to order

There are two families of pops: fruity ones, many of them vegan, and creamy ones made with dairy. “There’s creamy and fruity, so it depends on what you’re in the mood for,” Victoria told WFSB. In the summer of 2022, the Daily Nutmeg counted about 35 flavors in the freezers at a time, from a repertoire of roughly 70.

The fruit pops. Strawberry Lemon, Pineapple Mango, Fruit Salad (grapefruit juice with pieces of fruit), Lychee Lime and Pineapple Orange Banana are among the fruit flavors. Victoria’s own favorite, she told WFSB, is Pineapple Ginger.

Two PopCentric pineapple lime ice pops in their wrappers, on a table scattered with paper pineapples and limes

The creamy pops. Cookies and Cream and Coconut Avocado are longtime customer favorites, Key Lime Yogurt is on the current list, and Root Beer Float is the one her own kids love. “I especially enjoy the creme based ones!!” Tonya wrote in her Google review.

Rows of vanilla PopCentric ice pops dipped in white coating and rainbow sprinkles, lined up in a cooler

Flavors by request. Victoria takes suggestions. Customers asked for Pink Lemonade, which she colors with hibiscus, and a Fruity Pebbles pop inspired by a TikTok trend, according to the Daily Nutmeg. Many of her customers, she said back then, “have been with me from the beginning.”

Party and seasonal pops. Sprinkle-dipped pops, red-white-and-blue Patriotic pops and custom-themed holiday pops show up for special occasions.

A tray packed with pink watermelon-style PopCentric ice pops on branded wooden sticks

Grown-up pops. For weddings and adult parties, PopCentric makes cocktail-inspired pops such as Lemon Drop, Peach Bellini, Cosmo and Margarita, served on sticks stamped “Over 21.”

Orange and yellow PopCentric cocktail pops on wooden sticks stamped “Over 21”

Something for the dog. Puppy Pops come with a no-hide chew stick, so the four-legged members of the family don’t have to watch.

PopCentric To Go. Pops are sold in a reusable insulated tote, so you can take a variety home. Flavors in the pouches include Strawberry Peach, Coconut Avocado, Raspberry Mango and Cookies and Cream.

A green PopCentric To Go insulated tote surrounded by flavor pouches including Strawberry Peach, Coconut Avocado, Strawberry Lemon, Raspberry Mango, Cookies and Cream and Pineapple Mango

The Jeep, the cart and the truck

Much of PopCentric’s business happens away from State Street. Victoria started out loading up her Jeep for parties, school events, birthdays and weddings. Now there is a pop cart with a teal umbrella and a food truck that travels anywhere in Connecticut, and schools and daycares can book a visit to treat a whole class.

The PopCentric “All Natural Popsicles” cart under a teal umbrella at a backyard birthday party, with kids and parents gathered around

Customers who booked the truck can’t say enough about it. “The truck was so fun to have and everyone loved the taste of the popsicles,” Anna Lisa wrote after a party. “In fact, I think the popsicles were the highlight of the party.” Christina booked it for a work event: “Service and Popsicle quality was great. Overall a pleasant experience from start to end.”

Four kids holding up green, pink, yellow and berry-filled PopCentric ice pops

“On hot days, there’s a line out the door and I love it,” Victoria told WFSB. Summer is the busy season. The rest of the year is quieter, which is when regulars like Jake call ahead. He first tried a Strawberry Lemonade pop at Jones Family Farms and “became addicted.” He works nearby, so one winter day he called the shop first, and the owner met him there at noon and helped him pick out flavors for his office. “So happy to support a local female run and owned business!” he wrote.

A lime-green Jeep wrapped in PopCentric Gourmet Ice Pops branding, parked under a green umbrella

PopCentric also sells through Grubhub, DoorDash and Uber Eats, offers surprise bags through Too Good To Go, and supplies other businesses wholesale.

IF YOU GO

PopCentric Gourmet Ice Pops, 55 State St., North Haven

Phone: 203-492-9411

Fall and winter hours: Monday–Friday 10 a.m.–2 p.m. (summer hours are longer). It’s a mom-owned shop, so call ahead on snow days.

Online: popcentricpops.com (events, food truck and wholesale)

Also: delivery through Grubhub, DoorDash and Uber Eats

Get North Haven news first: subscribe to the North Haven Courier newsletter.

Have a tip? Email news@northhavencourier.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *